For many Pennsylvania homeowners, stepping over a high bathtub wall becomes one of the biggest obstacles to safe bathing. Whether due to aging, limited mobility, injury recovery, or long-term accessibility needs, creating a safer, low-barrier bathing environment is a priority — and two common solutions emerge:
Both improve accessibility, but they differ dramatically in cost, installation time, design flexibility, and long-term suitability. This guide breaks down the differences, who each option is best for, and what Pennsylvania homeowners should consider before choosing.
A tub cut (also known as a bathtub cut-out or tub-to-shower conversion insert) involves cutting a portion of the existing tub wall and installing a low-profile threshold. This creates a safer step-in entry without replacing the entire tub.
A full bathroom remodel replaces the existing tub or shower entirely — often replacing it with a walk-in shower, roll-in shower, or fully ADA-compliant redesign.
This is the most comprehensive way to achieve long-term accessibility.
Pricing varies by region and materials, but here are realistic ranges for PA in 2026:
While a tub cut is cheaper upfront, a full remodel may be more cost-effective over time if mobility needs are expected to increase.
If safety is your primary concern — especially for wheelchair users — a full remodel is usually the better long-term choice.
Choose a tub cut if you:
It’s a great transitional solution when major mobility changes are not expected in the next 3–5 years.
Choose a full remodel if you:
This option gives the most longevity and the safest overall environment.
Many Pennsylvania homes — especially older Pittsburgh, Philadelphia, and Harrisburg properties — were built with narrow bathrooms. These spaces often lack:
A tub cut may work in these layouts, but a full remodel provides better long-term solutions.
PA’s humid summers and cold winters can contribute to mold, water damage, and tile cracking. A remodeled shower with updated waterproofing materials can significantly reduce future maintenance.
Barrier-free showers and modern accessibility updates have become desirable for multigenerational households, especially in growing metro areas like Pittsburgh. A full remodel adds more resale value than a tub cut.
A tub cut is not recommended if:
In these cases, a fully accessible remodel should be considered.
Situation
Best Option
Limited budget
Tub cut
Need fast installation
Tub cut
Want maximum long-term safety
Full remodel
Wheelchair accessibility required
Full remodel
Aging in place long-term
Full remodel
Home will be sold soon
Full remodel (better ROI)
Can shower standing
Tub cut
Both solutions improve safety — it just depends on your needs, mobility, and long-term plans.
Whether you’re considering a tub cut, a barrier-free shower, or a full ADA-compliant remodel, having a professional evaluation ensures you choose the right solution.
We specialize in:
Nov 27, 2025
Barrier-free showers — also known as roll-in or curbless showers — have become one of the most requested accessibility upgrades for homeowners in Pittsburgh.
Nov 24, 2025
Wheelchair ramps are one of the most effective ways to make a home safely accessible. Whether you're supporting an aging parent, accommodating a loved one with mobility limitations, or preparing your home for long-term aging in place, choosing the right ramp is essential for comfort, safety, and independence.
Nov 21, 2025
While ADA regulations do not legally apply to private homes, many homeowners choose to follow ADA guidelines when remodeling a bathroom for aging in place, mobility challenges, or disability accommodations.
Nov 18, 2025
For homeowners with mobility challenges, improving access to porches, decks, garages, or different levels of the home often comes down to two primary solutions: a vertical platform lift (VPL) or a ramp.
